The modern dungeon master sits behind their screen like a wannabe Spielberg, orchestrating encounters as if Michael Bay were peering over their shoulder, nodding at each explosion. We’ve become directors of impossible spectacle, conductors of an orchestra that only plays fortissimo. Every adventure must culminate in killing a god, preventing the collapse of reality, or at minimum, saving an entire kingdom from certain doom.
What started as innocent fun—friends gathering around kitchen tables rolling oddly shaped dice—has transformed into a bizarre arms race of narrative escalation. Your party merely saved a village? How quaint. Mine just defeated an ancient dracolich while riding motorcycles made of crystallized time.
I know because I’ve been there myself. I found myself planning a campaign finale involving three simultaneous apocalypses, wondering if it was “epic enough” to satisfy my players. The absurdity only struck me later.
We’ve become junkies for the spectacular, chasing that initial high of genuine awe. And like all addictions, the returns are diminishing, the thrills more fleeting, and beneath it all, a hollowness grows where something more substantial used to reside.
We’ve become directors of impossible spectacle, architects of cosmic battles, yet we may have lost the art of making players care about what they’re saving.
The Epic Addiction
The fault is not in our dice, but in ourselves. We’ve developed a dependency on ‘moments’—those screenshot-worthy crescendos that dominate game night recaps. We plan our sessions around manufacturing these highlights, meticulously crafting scenarios where the wizard can dramatically collapse the ancient temple on the horde of undead with a perfectly timed Earthquake spell. We’ve become less storytellers and more moment-engineers, constructing elaborate setups for increasingly diminishing payoffs.
Social media has become our confessional, where we humble-brag about spectacular moments: “You guys won’t BELIEVE what my players did last night!” followed by 800 words about someone using Mage Hand to tickle a villain at a crucial moment. Meanwhile, the quiet campaign where characters developed meaningful relationships sits unmentioned, like the shy kid at a party full of theater majors—nobody posts about the session where the party just talked to townspeople, nobody writes a viral thread about the relief on the herbalist’s face when adventurers returned with the rare fungus needed to cure her daughter’s illness.
Professional Actual Plays have only fueled this addiction. As audiences watch celebrity DMs orchestrate elaborate set pieces with custom miniatures and trained voice actors, the average game master feels inadequate. These carefully edited productions create impossible standards. GMs now feel pressure to deliver Critical Role-worthy performances every Thursday night at Dave’s apartment. The quiet moments get sacrificed for performative excitement.
In our quest for ever-greater spectacle, we’ve forgotten that true epic moments aren’t measured by the size of the threat, but by the depth of our connection to what’s being threatened.
We’ve forgotten that Frodo’s journey wasn’t compelling because he slaughtered thousands of orcs with dual-wielded magic swords, but because he was small, afraid, and yet persisted anyway.
The Corporate Marketing Machine
The publishers aren’t helping. Open any modern RPG sourcebook and count the illustrations showing quiet moments of character development versus warriors mid-leap against Lovecraftian nightmares with too many eyes and an anxiety-inducing number of tentacles.
Look at the evolution of D&D modules over the decades. We’ve gone from “Keep on the Borderlands” (a simple fort with nearby caves containing kobolds) to adventures where level 1 characters are immediately thrust into cosmic conflicts. The escalation is relentless—Avernus isn’t just hell, it’s the first layer of the nine hells, because regular hell apparently lacks sufficient production value.
Adventure modules promise apocalypses with the casual frequency of seasonal allergies. “The fate of the multiverse hangs in the balance” appears so often in marketing copy that it should be followed by “again” in parentheses. Even the language has shifted. Adventures aren’t just “challenging” or “exciting” anymore—they’re “epic sagas,” “legendary campaigns,” and “world-shattering adventures.”
In the RPG industry’s race to the spectacular, we’ve confused epic scale with epic meaning. The fate of the universe is now the minimum viable product—but no apocalypse ever hit as hard as a beloved NPC’s betrayal.
Modern character options make us feel like unstoppable heroes. Gone are the days when “town guard” was a respectable career aspiration. Now your level three character must have a backstory involving at least one dead god, three betrayals, and a mysterious power that makes veteran adventurers whisper your name across the realm.
This isn’t entirely the publishers’ fault. They’re responding to market demands. We collectively asked for this, and now we’re drowning in content that promises earth-shattering consequences for every decision, as if every session needs the stakes of a season finale.
The Revolutionary Power of the Mundane
Yet in this hurricane of spectacle, what we’ve forgotten is an essential truth: the most memorable moments in roleplaying are often the quietest ones. Genuine power lurks in the spaces between explosions.
I’ll never forget the session where my players organized a funeral for a fallen NPC blacksmith who’d quietly supplied them with discounted weapons for months. They spent hours designing a memorial and tracking down his estranged daughter to deliver his savings. No combat, no puzzles—just genuine care for someone who’d existed on the periphery of their adventures.
How do we resist the gravitational pull of spectacle and create more grounded narratives? The answer isn’t in some five-step process—it’s in recognizing that the small and ordinary already contains everything we’re desperately manufacturing through cosmic threats.
Remember when your fighter taught the party a traditional hunting technique from her homeland? Or when your party spent three sessions helping a village solve their water shortage, not because it connected to some prophecy, but simply because people were thirsty? These moments land with the impact of a critical hit precisely because they’re not trying to be spectacular—they’re just genuinely human.
The humble tavern—that clichéd starting point we’ve all mockingly rolled our eyes at—contains within its walls a microcosm more dynamic than any astral battlefield. The innkeeper who remembers faces but forgets names. The traveling merchant who pays for drinks with stories instead of coin. The local champion arm-wrestler with a reputation to defend. None of these characters need to secretly be disguised gods to matter. They’re compelling precisely because they’re recognizably, stubbornly human in a world that keeps trying to be something else.
Small stories don’t just matter—they’re what make the big stories worth telling. A dragon threatening nameless thousands is statistics; a dragon threatening the innkeeper who remembers your drink order is an emergency.
I often wonder: how many campaigns have I rushed through, pushing toward some grand finale, when the real story was happening in the quiet moments I treated as mere stepping stones?
We don’t need another climactic battle where the fate of the cosmos hangs by a thread. We need more sessions where the goal isn’t saving the world, but simply making it a slightly better place—a place worth saving when the inevitable apocalypse does come knocking. Here’s the beautiful irony—these quieter adventures actually amplify the impact of your occasional forays into the spectacular.
When players spend weeks invested in the politics of a small town, the dragon that eventually threatens is a genuine crisis involving places and people they care about. Small stories make big feelings, and intimate scenarios can produce moments just as epic as any cosmic battle. And in a hobby that exists to generate feelings, that’s not a compromise—it’s the whole point.
Reclaiming Agency Through the Mundane
Here’s a paradox: the more world-ending the threat, the less meaningful the players’ choices often feel. When facing the God of Ultimate Destruction Who Will Definitely Destroy Everything Unless Stopped™, players really only have one choice—stop the god. The illusion of agency evaporates as the stakes approach infinity.
Contrast this with smaller, more intimate scenarios. When deciding whether to support the current mayor of a town or her rival in the upcoming election, players have genuine choices. Both options are viable, both have merits and drawbacks, and players can fully understand the implications of their decision.
When every choice is about saving the world, no choice matters. True agency thrives in the small decisions that change one life at a time.
Small-scale storytelling expands player agency. When the party discovers a dispute between two farming families over water rights during a drought, players might negotiate a sharing agreement, seek out a druid to magically enhance the well’s output, investigate if someone is secretly diverting the water upstream, research ancient irrigation techniques in the town archives, or simply choose a side to support. There’s no single “right” approach dictated by the Monster Manual.
These intimate scenarios enable what we supposedly value most in RPGs: creative problem-solving and meaningful character development. Your paladin’s approach to resolving a bitter water dispute between struggling farmers reveals far more about their moral compass than which smite-enhancing oath they swore at level 3.
Conclusion: Balance in All Things
I’m not suggesting we abandon epic storytelling entirely. There’s undeniable joy in those moments when the bard’s clutch Inspiration die turns a miss into a hit that defeats the ancient lich. We all enjoy occasionally saving the world—it’s why we play fantasies rather than “Medieval Peasant Life Simulator 1392.”
What I am advocating for is balance—a thoughtful integration of the personal and the spectacular. The world-ending threat feels more significant when we’ve spent time in the world and grown to care about its inhabitants beyond their function as potential casualties in a villain’s master plan.
The best campaigns I’ve experienced operate like a fractal—at every level of zoom, from personal conflicts to cosmic threats, there’s interesting detail and meaningful choice. The impending demon invasion matters precisely because we’ve spent time in the city, know the shopkeepers by name, have favorite taverns, and can imagine specific faces among the potential victims.
So plan your epic boss battles and world-threatening cataclysms. But between these operatic set pieces, make room for the quiet duets, the subtle characterization, and the gentle moments of connection. Your campaigns will be richer for it, your players will develop deeper attachments to the world, and you’ll discover that sometimes, the most spectacular moments are the ones where not a single die is rolled.
After all, when the cosmic dust settles and the campaign ends, what players reminisce about years later isn’t usually how many d6s of damage they rolled that one time. It’s the night the party sat around a campfire and finally got the truth about the rogue’s mysterious scar. It’s the session where the normally stoic cleric broke down after finding the shrine to their forgotten deity, lovingly maintained by a single elderly devotee for decades.
It’s the quiet moments that, paradoxically, make the most noise in our memories.
I know mine do.
Featured image: Man and Woman Contemplating the Moon by Caspar David Friedrich (1824)
Leave a Reply